Hawk Sista wrote:Whether or not the Allen situation is point by point comparable or not does not change my overriding premise. My point is that going after and paying Suh and the 16+million he WILL get is a. not possible and b. Not our style. On the other side, whether or not Suh wants to play here, he's not going to leave millions on the table to do it. I'd be happy to be wrong.
Hawk Sista wrote:Whether or not the Allen situation is point by point comparable or not does not change my overriding premise. My point is that going after and paying Suh and the 16+million he WILL get is a. not possible and b. Not our style. On the other side, whether or not Suh wants to play here, he's not going to leave millions on the table to do it. I'd be happy to be wrong.
HumanCockroach wrote:Again, you and others are welcome to believe whatever you want in regards to Suh. No where have I posted they should sign him, my posts revolve around the feasability of signing him, and the effects it would have on the defense, some of the ramifications of signing him, and nothing else. What it would "do" to the chemistry is an unknown, what it would do to the cap moving forward is unknown, whether he would take less to come home, is an unknown... Lots of unknowns, I'm posting on what IS known ( ie, he could be signed, his level of play, what that would mean to players like Bennett, Avril, Irvin as well as the DB's etc).
HumanCockroach wrote:Wouldn't be overly surprised to see Seattle draft a pass rushing Tackle and sign a FA receiver ( I prefer this vastly over overpaying for Suh, or trading for Marshall.... If they are smart about it and a little bit lucky they could also look for a pass receiving TE as well without hamstringing themselves....
NorthHawk wrote:Here is how Rotoworld has ranked the Interior DL Free Agents for this year.
It's interesting (to me, at least) how high they have Williams ranked considering how many miles are on those tires.
The list:
Interior Defensive Linemen
1. Ndamukong Suh
2. Nick Fairley
3. Terrance Knighton
4. Dan Williams
5. Jared Odrick
6. Stephen Paea
7. C.J. Mosley
8. Henry Melton
9. Cory Redding
10. Letroy Guion
11. Corey Peters
12. B.J. Raji
13. Kevin Williams
14. Kenrick Ellis
15. Ahtyba Rubin
16. Tom Johnson
17. Jarvis Jenkins
18. Alan Branch
19. Alex Carrington
20. Dwan Edwards
21. Pat Sims
22. Tommy Kelly
23. Mike Patterson
24. Leger Douzable
25. Karl Klug
26. Colin Cole
27. Kevin Vickerson
28. Tyson Alualu
29. Demarcus Dobbs
30. Brandon Deaderick
31. Andre Fluellen
32. Fili Moala
33. D'Anthony Smith
34. Nick Hayden
35. Jarius Wynn
36. Chris Neild
37. Ricardo Mathews
38. Mitch Unrein
39. Terrence Cody
40. C.J. Wilson
IMO the difference between the Denver SB and the NE SB very well may have come down to that one element...
Brady can't step up numerous times and complete a 3rd and 14 we may be discussing something entirely different this off season than why the hell didn't they run the ball from the one. HC
And my point is A it ABSOLUTELY IS possible B I'm not advocating it C anyone claiming this wouldn't improve the team haven't watched him play D for the "right" player Seattle will indeed spend the money ( and in Harvins case, even if he isn't the "right" player)...
HumanCockroach wrote:Hell according to Clayton we couldn't retain Kam, ET, Sherman either, nor could we keep Avril and Bennett.... Clayton has a "formula" he is constantly referencing in regards to the "amount" of 6 million + players a team can have on it's roster, Seattle already has MORE than Claytons formula allows, and has 23 million dollars in space to boot. The difference between Seattle and other teams is the ability to take cast offs, late picks etc, and develop them into good to very good situational, or back up players. Instead of PAYING millions to the third string DT, we draft one late, and get mileage out of them...
Players would HAVE to go to allow Suh in Seattle, but the truth is, some of those players are older, and more expensive than a rookie backup would be. Mebane IMHO is either going to rework his contract, or be let go in a scenario like that, Wilson likely will play this season under his current salary with a big extension ( the same as every player they have signed in the recent past) as will more than likely Wagner. Seattle hasn't shown a perpensity to "tear up" existing contracts, but the have shown a willingness to pay exceptional players. The Landscape hasn't "changed" as much as you are saying. Every team makes tough choices moving forward, and signing Suh would create simply more of them.
I know Clayton quotes that formula like it came out of the football bible or something. I generally like the idea of Clayton but often find he doesn't have all the answers he thinks he has.
NorthHawk wrote:This discussion might be moot as Mayhew said today that although a deal hasn't yet been reached, the essential elements are in place.
Steady_Hawk wrote:Zorn,
I'm not so sure. Pete went to great lengths to get Percy, and Suh would be easier as no trade compensation would be required. We don't have the room for Suh without cutting for it. We could make the room. Now, if Suh's all about the payday you are right, we won't be in the Suh sweepstakes, but if he's serious about wanting to play in Seattle they could make him the highest paid DT and keep the cap from imploding at the same time. We would lose 3-4 players to make it happen, which I'm okay with personally, but I understand others reluctance on this matter. Also, the cap has been going up lately. I'm not sure if that will hit a ceiling soon, but if it made another 10 Mil jump that would make Suh's contract that much easier to afford. On top of that, I believe we have 7 Mil in dead cap space that opens up next year from the Harvin experiment.
I don't think there is anyway Detroit retains Suh. They can't afford to FT him, and it sounds like he wants out of Detroit quite frankly. Again, this is a move I think you have to make if you can. Suh would take this Defense to a new level. I have fantasized what this D would look like with Tez loading the middle, and now we could possibly see it with Suh.
Times a ticking. March 2nd will be here very soon.
Users browsing this forum: NorthHawk and 33 guests