NorthHawk wrote:Still does not say who he drafted or what he did. You are just taking a period in time, ignoring that we did not build this team solely through the draft, and assuming McGloughan is somehow the reason.
I'm not going to keep posting how this team was built given any Seattle fan should know.
McGloughan did not build the Super Bowl team. That is just BS.
In your mind somehow McGloughan found everyone of our good players in the draft, convinced Carroll and Schneider to draft them, and built the team while Pete and John buffooned around going, "McGloughan, what would do with out you?" That just such a ridiculous idea I see getting posted over and over again. The idea that one guy in the organization has that much power to get players drafted and scouts them all and just knows better than everyone else like that's how NFL scouting and drafting works.
Just look at the results. Some people just have a good eye for talent that fits and can have a huge influence on who to select. That's the reality of the draft and how it works.
When McGloughan was here as Senior Personnel Executive we selected 8 players that were named to the Pro Bowl or All Pro.
Since he left we've selected 4 players to do that of which 1 is a punter. Brooks and Taylor might add to that list, but still
8 in 2 years vs 4 in 7 drafts.
You're full of crap. One guy did not have a hand in drafting all those players, so stop painting a false picture of how drafting works. He also could not get Pete and John to agree to draft them.
I look at the results and I believe Pete and John are mostly responsible. This myth of McGloughan is just that a myth bought into by a small segment of Seattle fans who don't know how drafting works and don't remember how this team was built such as forgetting that Michael Bennett and Cliff Avril were brought in during free agency. Or that scheme is how we took advantage of overlooked large CBs and safeties like Sherm and Kam. Pete Carroll brought back a style of football not seen in the NFL for a while and was able to take over-sized safeties and DBs and make them shine because of how he set up the scheme.
Or that we traded for Lynch from Buffalo and Pete Carroll knew Lynch well from his days playing against him the PAC 12.
You want to forget how this team was built in and believe in the myth of McGloughan, not much I can do to change your mind.
But I know and anyone who follows this team well or remembers how this team was built know that is rubbish. No one bet on Russell Wilson except John Schneider who scouted him personally. Everyone thought Seattle were fools for drafting Russell Wilson and giving him the chance to start at his height, which is why he fell to the 3rd round. I don't think McGloughan had anything to do with Russell Wilson. It was mostly John Schneider and then Pete Carroll for believing in him.
The Super Bowl team was nothing more than a bunch of moves that included key moves other than the draft to build a magical team. Pete Carroll coached that team up to historical production including crafting a throwback defense with a historically great secondary from one first rounder, two fifth rounders, and a cast off from Canada. That had nothing to do with McGloughan. The type of DBs Carroll wanted were of his devising. They weren't even guys anyone was drafting at the time as that style of secondary wasn't in vogue in the NFL.
I credit Carroll for bringing back an old school scheme and knowing which players he could use that no one wanted to implement it. I credit Schneider for believing in an undersized QB that no one was much willing to give a chance to that John believed in and sold the head coach on. I credit Carroll for seeing what Lynch could be in Seattle and creating the environment for Lynch to thrive.
I credit Dan Quinn for his great D-line work. Brandon Mebane was drafted before McGloughan arrived. Smart to keep him seeing he was a good fit for Carroll's scheme. Maybe Dan for knowing Michael Bennett as Bennett was drafted when Quinn was here the first time. Cliff Avril was just a good free agency pick up. Dan Quinn coached up the D-line and did a great job doing it.
Maybe McGloughan had a hand in Bobby Wagner. I don't know.
This whole myth of McGloughan is just a bunch of hogwash that people who know all the little parts that had to come together to create the magic of that Seattle Seahawks football team were so many that each piece added to the greater whole to create that four years of dominance. Gonna be hard to recreate no matter what we do as those types of perfect storms don't happen very often in franchise history.